Philly Italian Pork is one of the tastiest things we have made in the Instant Pot. As soon as the natural release was done, I found myself slurping the gravy by the spoonful. This recipe begins with the journey by Woks of Life’s Kaitlin to recreate the pork sandwiches she ate at Tommy DiNic’s while in college, then makes a swerve into reader Donna’s Instant Pot version which she says is even better. Makes many servings.
Ingredients
Pork butt, picnic or shoulder cut, bone-in or not, 4-6 lbs
½ c finely chopped garlic (about 16 cloves)
2 T dried oregano
2 T dried fennel
1 T dried thyme
1 T dried rosemary
1 ½ T Kosher salt
2 yellow onions, peeled and sliced thin
Olive oil
½ c red wine
14 oz can chopped tomatoes
2 bay leaves
2 c chicken stock
Method: Cut the pork into large chunks, reserving any bones. Mix salt, chopped garlic and dried spices and rub over all surfaces of the pork. Marinate overnight in the refrigerator.
In the morning, sauté onions in ¼ c olive oil till transparent; reserve. Sauté pork chunks in batches, turning to expose all sides and cook till light brown and crispy. After last chunk is removed, deglaze pot with red wine then add back onions and pork chunks as well as the reserved bone. Add chicken stock, tomato and bay leaves. Pressure cook on Manual for 60 minutes followed by 30 minutes natural release. Discard bones and bay leaves. The pork is ready to eat immediately, though if you refrigerate overnight it will throw off a layer of fat you might want to scrape up and discard.
Serving suggestion: the classic way to serve Instant Pot Italian Philly Pork is on a puffy Italian roll: split the roll, add a layer of provolone (sharp preferred) and toast till cheese is melted, then pile on pork with a good amount of juice. Addition of sautéed broccoli rabe or spinach is a must; a relish of sautéed long hot peppers and bell peppers is optional (and offered at extra cost at DiNic’s, I believe). There are jars of sliced pepperoncini on the counter at DiNics for a finishing touch; we had pickled cherry peppers and used those instead.
Instant Pot Italian Philly Pork is also mighty good without the roll, served over polenta or just on its own in a bowl with a spoon to capture every molecule of herb-specked gravy. Date night note: this method is a lot neater than the sandwich, which tends to disintegrate into sloppy goodness that ends up on your shirt.














